The Room101 Johnny Tobacconaut can be traced all the way back to 2015 when Room101 was still an independent company and was being distributed by Davidoff. Matt Booth, founder of Room101 and Room101 Brands introduced the Johnny Tobacconaut alongside a mascot of a spaceman holding a shovel with tobacco leaves on his back, and thus the Johnny Tobacconaut brand as a whole was born. It was a limited edition cigar that was originally made at the Camacho factory in Honduras as a Nicaraguan puro.
In 2021, Booth reintroduced Johnny Tobacconaut albeit with A.J. Fernandez at the helm of production. This time it was released as an exclusive for Luxury Cigar Club. However, after the sale of Room101 to Scandinavian Tobacco Group, the company decided to introduce the brand as core-line production in robusto, toro and the original perfecto formats with a Connecticut-seed wrapper. In 2025, Johnny Tobacconaut celebrated its 10th Anniversary with a special limited edition release with a darker wrapper and available only as a 6 x 52 size. This year, STG and Room101 introduced the Johnny Tobacconaut Maduro, expanding the core-line of the JT series.
- Origin: Nicaragua
- Factory: Tabacalera AJ Fernandez Cigars de Nicaragua S.A.
- Wrapper: Nicaragua
- Binder: Nicaragua
- Filler: Nicaragua
- Size: Robusto – 5 x 50
- MSRP: $10.29 / Box of 20 – $205.80
- Release Date: June 5th, 2026
The Johnny Tobacconaut Maduro is also available in two other sizes:
- Toro – 6 x 52: $11.39 (Box – $227.80)
- Gordo – 6 x 60: $12.49 (Box – $249.80)
Pre-Light

The wrapper is veiny and toothy, giving me a real antique leather appearance, with a small amount of sheen from some oil. On the nose, smelling the cigar I get a rich smell of barnyard and manure. I think back to a conversation that I had with a friend who works in a local shop who told me “you know a cigar is going to taste great when it smell smells like shit” and I don’t mean to write that with a negative connotation. I write this saying that I really hope he’s right because I have high hopes for the cigar and if his logic is correct, then this cigar should taste fantastic but time will tell. Once I cut the cigar and I take a cold draw, I get some sea salt fresh out of the grinder, a smidge of white truffle with just a mist of sweetness on the finish that quickly disappears. Overall, I find the cold draw to not be super flavorful. The draw is pretty average, not being super loose or super tight, it is just where I like it.
First Third

I take the first few puffs and I immediately get a heavy mouthful of flavor. The JT maduro is very dark, very rich, not super spicy -more earthy with char dark and rich cocoa powder. I mean right out of the gate, this is a full-body flavor profile. As it cools off a little bit, there is some white pepper in the middle, but it’s not the dominating flavor. Regardless, that flavor note is there and it lingers but the Earth, leather, cocoa and char – especially the char – are really the dominating characteristics so far in this cigar. In addition, the JT maduro Robusto does offer plenty of smoke production.
As I continue to smoke the first third of the cigar, the flavor strength does come down a little bit in intensity and strength, but the same taste is there nonetheless. It is just not as bold as the first few puffs. Mostly, the char and dried-out leather are the dominant flavors in the cigar so if you like a cigar with a lot of char and earthiness, this is definitely going to be right up your alley. But if you like a cigar with more sweetness and softness, I am just having a hard time finding that here. The only positive for me right now is the JT maduro is burning pretty good at this point, giving me a nice bright white ash that is tightly stacked together and giving off plenty of smoke.
Second Third

Transitioning from the first third to the second third, I start to get a little bit of a corn chip taste like a Chex Mix or a Chex cereal. Better yet, even like a fresh bag of Bugles. There is still not a lot of sweetness, but savory corn chip is the big standout flavor at this point in the game, while still overpowered by a thick char and a lingering dry leather taste. It is also at this point where I noticed on two out of the three samples the cigar starts to burn a little bit more uneven, not crazy out of whack, but it’s not perfect so it’s going to lose points there. I also have to try to slow down the burn a little bit because I noticed in addition to that it does begin to burn a little bit faster the rest of the way. I have also been giving the cigar small touchups since the end of the first third and it will lose additional points there as well.
The corn chip taste hangs around for a while, but does eventually fade away. Mostly, the char and old leather continue to dominate the flavor profile in this cigar. I am past halfway at this point, which tells me the cigar isn’t as complex as I hoped it would be. It leans more on the one-dimensional side, which is very disappointing. I am also not a huge fan of this flavor profile either and while others might enjoy it for me it is undesireable.
Final Third

As I prepare for the final stretch into the final third, and if I am being honest, I am just ready for the cigar to be over. It is one dimensional. I get the same flavor that I have mostly tasted through this entire cigar. I feel like a broken record by just repeating it so I won’t because you already know what I taste. If anything, I will add that it’s gotten increasingly bitter almost as if the tobacco is too young and it is not fermented enough. It almost feels like razor blades in my mouth. I can’t drink enough water to cleanse the palate enough to get this taste out of my mouth. For me, the cigar is a swing in a miss.
Smokin Wrap
I had higher hopes for this cigar, but unfortunately the Johnny Tobacconaut Maduro isn’t on the same wavelength as its original predecessor. It is also very rare that I have such a disappointment in an A.J. Fernandez made cigar. Usually, A.J Fernandez is a name I read and almost don’t need to continue because it is a sure thing. But even Michael Jordan and Tom Brady had off days where they lost the game. Room101 as a whole also usually smokes very well regardless of blend for me, but this is one I won’t revisit and if I may add – stick to the original Johnny Tobacconaut cigars.
Smokin Facts
- Room101 does not advertise with Smokin Tabacco
- STG does not advertise with Smokin Tabacco
- Cigars were purchased by Smokin Tabacco
- The original Johnny Tobacconaut Robusto was our #5 Cigar of the Year in 2023
- Average Smoking Time: 55 Minutes
